Current:Home > MarketsCould Biden "shut down" the border now? What to know about the latest immigration debate -Wealth Empowerment Zone
Could Biden "shut down" the border now? What to know about the latest immigration debate
View
Date:2025-04-13 16:19:32
Washington — There's currently an intense debate about what legal authorities President Biden has at his disposal to deal with the humanitarian crisis at the U.S. southern border, where migrant apprehensions have reached record levels in recent years.
The debate escalated recently after Mr. Biden promised to "shut down" the U.S.-Mexico border if Congress passes an immigration compromise that his administration has been negotiating with a small bipartisan group of senators. While the agreement has not been officially released, sources directly familiar with the talks have told CBS News that it would give the executive branch the power to partially shut down asylum processing when illegal border crossings reach certain levels.
Mr. Biden's pledge to "shut down the border" was likely shorthand for clamping down on illegal crossings and asylum claims, since completely shutting down an international boundary would bring legal travel and trade to a halt — an unprecedented move that would hurt both the U.S. and Mexican economies.
Here are the facts about what Mr. Biden can do now legally at the border and what he can't do, at least without congressional intervention:
What authority does Biden currently have?
Mr. Biden has the legal authority to reinstate the border policies implemented by former President Donald Trump that he ended, since they were based on proclamations, regulations and international agreements.
Those now-defunct Trump policies include agreements that allowed the U.S. to reroute asylum-seekers to third countries and the "Remain in Mexico" program, which required migrants to await their asylum hearings outside of the U.S. Federal law allows officials to return asylum-seekers to Mexico, but it does not require it, as decreed by the Supreme Court in 2022.
U.S. law also gives the president, through the attorney general and the secretary of homeland security, the power to place limits on asylum. And Mr. Biden already has.
After the Title 42 pandemic-related border restrictions ended last spring, the Biden administration enacted a regulation that presumes migrants are ineligible for asylum if they enter the U.S. without using any of the legal immigration pathways it created and have passed through a third country without seeking asylum. But the administration has not been able to implement the asylum restriction at scale because it does not have the necessary officers, detention facilities and money.
The president, however, does not currently have the legal authority to unilaterally suspend U.S. asylum law, which grants migrants on American soil the right to request humanitarian refuge, even when they cross into the country illegally.
Only Congress can change U.S. asylum law.
Did Trump try to "shut down" asylum claims at the border?
Yes, and his efforts were struck down in federal court.
Trump tried to single-handedly suspend asylum in between ports of entry along the southern border through a proclamation in 2018, using a law House Speaker Mike Johnson and other Republicans have urged Mr. Biden to invoke.
While the Supreme Court allowed the Trump administration to use this law — known as Section 212(f) — to enact restrictions and bans on legal immigration and travel, such as the infamous "travel bans," federal courts prevented the government from citing this authority to suspend asylum law. Trump's 2018 rule was ultimately declared unlawful.
What authorities would the emerging deal in Congress give Biden?
The emerging deal in the Senate would effectively give Mr. Biden — and his successors, for that matter — the power Trump sought to invoke in that 2018 proclamation.
It would allow or require the Department of Homeland Security to partially suspend asylum law in between official ports of entry when there's a spike in illegal crossings. Sources familiar with the deal said the power would be mandated after average daily migrant crossings hit 5,000 over seven days, or 8,500 in a single day. It could also be activated on a discretionary basis after average daily crossings surpass 4,000 in a week.
When the authority is invoked, migrants who cross into the U.S. illegally would not be allowed to ask for asylum, and would face swift deportation to Mexico or their home country. Access to the U.S. asylum system would be preserved at official border crossings.
Camilo Montoya-GalvezCamilo Montoya-Galvez is the immigration reporter at CBS News. Based in Washington, he covers immigration policy and politics.
TwitterveryGood! (3)
Related
- Backstage at New York's Jingle Ball with Jimmy Fallon, 'Queer Eye' and Meghan Trainor
- FBI investigates after 176 gravestones at Jewish cemeteries found vandalized in Ohio
- 2 inmates escape from a Mississippi jail while waiting for murder trials
- Sierra Leone outlaws child marriage. Even witnesses to such weddings can face jail time.
- All That You Wanted to Know About She’s All That
- Poisons in paradise: How Mexican cartels target Hawaii with meth, fentanyl
- Alabama state Sen. Garlan Gudger injured in jet ski accident, airlifted to hospital
- Are shark attacks on the rise? | The Excerpt
- Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
- 1 killed, 10 injured as speedboat crashes into jetty in California
Ranking
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- Halle Bailey, DDG reveal face of baby Halo for first time: See the photos
- Vanessa Hudgens gives birth to first baby with husband Cole Tucker: 'Happy and healthy'
- ATV crashes into pickup on rural Colorado road, killing 2 toddlers and 2 adults
- McKinsey to pay $650 million after advising opioid maker on how to 'turbocharge' sales
- Wisconsin Supreme Court changes course, will allow expanded use of ballot drop boxes this fall
- Accessorize With Early Amazon Prime Day Jewelry Deals: 42 Earrings for $13.99, $5.39 Necklaces & More
- What to look for in the U.S. government's June jobs report
Recommendation
Meta donates $1 million to Trump’s inauguration fund
Firefighters make progress against California wildfire, but heat and fire risks grow in the West
Rail cars carrying hazardous material derail and catch fire in North Dakota
Backers of raising Ohio’s minimum wage to $15 an hour fail to get it on this year’s ballot
The Best Stocking Stuffers Under $25
Gymnast MyKayla Skinner Says Her Controversial Comments About 2024 Olympics Team Were Misinterpreted
Storms kill man in Kansas after campers toppled at state park; flood watches continue
Delaware judge refuses to dismiss lawsuit in battle over estate of the late pop icon Prince