Current:Home > MarketsMeta's Threads wants to become a 'friendly' place by downgrading news and politics -Wealth Empowerment Zone
Meta's Threads wants to become a 'friendly' place by downgrading news and politics
View
Date:2025-04-16 07:00:47
Days after the public launch of Twitter rival Threads, Meta executive Adam Mosseri was surprisingly transparent about the company's distaste for the news media: Meta will not be doing anything to encourage hard news and politics on the platform, he wrote.
Amid Twitter's turmoil under Elon Musk, more than 100 million people have rushed to join Threads, making it the most swiftly adopted app in history.
But if Meta executives have their way, Threads will not be where people turn to debate policy issues, or catch up on local political developments and learn about breaking news that could affect their lives.
Instead, Threads is being offered as a text-version of Instagram, where celebrities, influencers and corporate brands dominate. Or as Meta chief Mark Zuckerberg put it, a "friendly" shelter from the noisy and chaotic world of news and politics.
"Will this decision make society dumber?" Solomon Messing, a former Facebook research scientist said in an interview with NPR. "Gosh, it's really hard not to say yes."
News isn't a big social media moneymaker
Messing, who is now a research professor at New York University, has published research examining how social media shapes the public's grasp of politics and news events, and how being exposed to news on social media influences someone's likelihood to vote.
The conclusion was fairly obvious.
"When folks see more political content in their news feeds, they tend to become more interested in politics," Messing said. "They tend to develop more consistent policy preferences. They tend to report voting at higher rates."
Yet to Meta, the business case is straightforward: Want a big return on investment, or ROI? Then start pushing anything other than news and politics.
Messing adds: "What's the ROI on being a politics-focused social network versus a celebrity-focused social network?"
Alex Stamos, former chief security officer at Facebook, said the company learned long ago that the news industry needs social media platforms more than the platforms need the news.
"Overall, the amount of engagement and therefore money the company makes from hard news has shown to be quite small," Stamos said.
Political drama has plenty of fans
What keeps people scrolling so persistently that it supercharges advertising revenue? "Interactions between individuals, the family photos, the influencers, things like that," he said.
Meta can turn the knobs up or down for certain kinds of content, Stamos said. For instance, Threads could de-emphasize posts that include a link to a news organization. "They'll be trying to strike the right balance between their desire to stay relevant counterbalanced with their desire to not be pulled into controversies," Stamos said.
But saying Threads is not interested in courting political drama is not going to stop it, especially with such an influx of users coming over from Twitter, which is, as Stamos put it, "effectively an intellectual gladiator coliseum. People are there to see blood on the floor."
Many of those departing Twitter because of Musk's changes to the platform are left-leaning critics of Musk who tweet obsessively about news and politics. So if Threads does not encourage discourse about politics, it might leave them without a real replacement social media app.
But can Meta really avoid the combative tenor of Twitter? It is an open question, Stamos argues, but he said Threads is kidding itself by saying it can be something of an online town square without fierce political debates.
"Whatever they're saying publicly, they clearly want to displace Twitter. And in order to do that they have to become a very important platform for political speech," Stamos said.
Meta has de-emphasized news before
In some ways, Meta's growing distance from the news industry is nothing new.
In 2016, Facebook made major changes to its algorithm to favor posts from friends and family over news articles. That decision eviscerated the traffic publishers once received from the social network.
On Instagram, major news organizations promote stories that can garner impressive engagement, but it is usually drowned out by much lighter content showing off vacations, weddings and lifestyle trends.
Then there is the Russia controversy that former Facebook employees say the company is still smarting from.
After the 2016 presidential election, American intelligence agencies found that Russian-linked disinformation campaigns created posts around divisive, hot-button topics that reached many millions in an attempt to meddle in the 2016 presidential election.
In 2020, Russia-backed groups attempted to meddle again in a presidential election by pushing conspiracy theories on social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter, but the efforts reached a far smaller audience.
Taken together, Meta executives want Threads to be a platform that makes the maximum amount of money, while steering clear of the kind of scrutiny that was heaped upon the company in the wake of the 2016 election.
But Brian Ott, a social media scholar who teaches at Missouri State University, said online platforms like Threads have a responsibility to encourage, not discourage, political debate and discussions that can influence how people engage in their communities and vote.
Ott said Meta is attempting to position Threads as an anti-Twitter Twitter, when in fact it is essentially a clone service.
"What Meta is engaged in right now is a marketing effort to try to tell people, 'hey this isn't going to be what happened last time,' well, in fact, it is going to be what happened last time," Ott said. "It's going to be exactly what happened last time. Because the fundamental technology hasn't changed."
veryGood! (7)
Related
- Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
- A major storm sweeping the US is expected to bring heavy rain, snow to East Coast this weekend
- If Jim Harbaugh leaves for NFL, he more than did his job restoring Michigan football
- Doctors and nurses at one of the nation's top trauma centers reflect on increase in gun violence
- Bodycam footage shows high
- Novak Djokovic stuns United Cup teammates by answering questions in Chinese
- Myanmar’s military government pardons 10,000 prisoners to mark Independence Day
- Want to stress less in 2024? A new book offers '5 resets' to tame toxic stress
- Intel's stock did something it hasn't done since 2022
- Family from Arkansas identified as victims in fatal Michigan home explosion
Ranking
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- Who won 2024's first Mega Millions drawing? See winning numbers for the $114 million jackpot
- How Google is using AI to help one U.S. city reduce traffic and emissions
- Georgia agency awards contract to raise Savannah bridge to accommodate bigger cargo ships
- Gen. Mark Milley's security detail and security clearance revoked, Pentagon says
- Japan police arrest a knife-wielding woman inside a train after 4 people are reported injured
- Why Fans Think Kendall Jenner & Bad Bunny Reunited After Breakup
- Vizio will pay $3M in settlement over refresh rates. Do you qualify for a payout?
Recommendation
John Galliano out at Maison Margiela, capping year of fashion designer musical chairs
Selena Gomez's Boyfriend Benny Blanco Shares Glimpse Into Their Romance
New York governor pushes for reading education overhaul as test scores lag
Starbucks' 2024 winter menu has Pistachio Latte, new snacks – and more ways to use your own cup
A White House order claims to end 'censorship.' What does that mean?
How Steelers can make the NFL playoffs: Scenarios, remaining schedule and postseason chances
Map shows the states where E. coli concerns led to recall of 7,000 pounds of beef
Mother and uncle of a US serviceman are rescued from Gaza in a secret operation